Sunday, January 03, 2010

How to Write a Great Query Letter: An Example That Worked

In May of 2006, a writer named Olugbemisola Rhuday-Perkovich sent me a query letter for a novel then called Long Time No Me. After several reads and a noncontractual revision, I acquired the book in December of 2007; and two years and a month later, that novel is now in stores as Eighth Grade Superzero -- praised as a "masterful debut" in a starred review from Publishers Weekly.

Gbemi has kindly allowed me to reprint her original letter here and annotate it as a companion to the Annotated Query Letter from Hell; I think of this as the Annotated Query Letter That Does It Right. Much of what it Does Right is that it speaks so specifically to me and my tastes, as you’ll see—my interest in writers of color and in racial, religious, and other moral questions—and clearly those tastes would not be applicable to all acquisitions editors. But if you can divine from an editor’s books, blog posts, talks at conferences, or other material what his or her tastes are, then this might hint at ways to tailor your description of your novel to fit those tastes. And if you have no idea about an editor’s tastes, this is still a useful example for its professionalism, efficiency, thoroughness, and overall grace. The numbers in parentheses are my annotations.

May 31, 2006

(1) Cheryl Klein
Arthur A. Levine Books
557 Broadway
New York, NY 10012

(2) Dear Ms. Klein:

(3) We met at the Rutgers University Council on Children’s Literature (RUCCL) One-on-One Plus Conference last October, and (4) I’ve since enjoyed your words on moral dilemmas and character values, as well as some of the books you’ve worked on. (5) I loved Lisa Yee’s painfully funny Millicent Min, Girl Genius, and Saxton Freymann’s Food for Thought has been a crafting inspiration as well as a teaching aid.

(6) In my middle-grade novel Long Time No Me, (7) Reginald “Pukey” McKnight created a superhero character in kindergarten; (8) now secretly dreams of being a real-life hero. (9) The Guy who’s got game and gets the Girl. Instead, he threw up on the first day of school. In the middle of the cafeteria. In front of everyone. 8th grade has gone downhill ever since.

(10) Now Reggie can’t even look The Girl in the eye, and his former best friend is bent on shredding his already tattered reputation. Sometimes he thinks it would be best to just exist between the lines and slide under the school’s social radar. (11) That won’t be easy when Reggie’s current best friend is white, a fact that seems to matter more and more, and his oldest friend is bent on “speaking truth to power” to anyone and everyone. (12) Reggie wonders why things are so bad if God is so good; his faith at all levels is challenged by (13) his father’s unemployment, his encounters with a homeless man, and his role as a “Big Buddy” to a younger version of himself. (14) When he finally decides to “be the change he wants to see” and run for school President, Reggie learns that sometimes winning big means living small.

(15) I’ve been published in national teen publications such as Rap Masters, Word Up, and Right On, and developed teen-oriented projects for clients including Queen Latifah, Girls, Inc., and Sunburst Communications. (16) I focused on my writing for children in workshops with Madeleine L’Engle and Paula Danziger, and was a three-time mentee at the RUCCL One-on-One Plus Conference. The Echoing Green Foundation twice awarded me a public service fellowship for my work with adolescent girls. I received my M.A. from New York University in Educational Communication and Technology with a concentration in Adolescent Literacy, and my B.Sc. from Cornell University in Print Communication. (17) I am a member of the Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators (SCBWI).

(18) Would you like to see sample chapters of Long Time No Me? An SASE is enclosed. I can be contacted at [phone number redacted] and by email at [email address redacted]. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

Olugbemisola Rhuday-Perkovich

(1) & (2) In the spirit of contrasting this with the Query Letter from Hell, it’s worth pointing out: She spells my name and gets my publishing house right, and refers to me as “Ms. Klein,” as is proper in business correspondence. I would call her “Ms. Rhuday-Perkovich” in turn.

(3) She identifies where we met, at the One-on-One Conference seven months previously. Even if I don’t remember an attendee specifically (which I often don’t, I confess, given that I attend three to six conferences a year), a line like this is useful in establishing that this isn’t a query out of the blue: The writer has heard me speak and knows something about me, my editorial values, and likely what I’m looking for, which increases the odds that this is a thoughtful query I will like, as opposed to a query-bomb directed to ten editors plucked at random from the Children’s Writer's and Illustrator's Market.

(4) She mentions material posted on my website or blog. I always appreciate small compliments like these, particularly when they show that the writer values the same things I value—in this case, moral dilemmas and characters with depth. However, I would caution writers not to place too much emphasis or spend too much time on these sorts of personal compliments to editors with blogs or websites or what have you: We judge a query on the description of the book and the strength of your writing, not how nice you are to us.

(5) She brings up two of the books I’ve edited, which again indicates that she knows something about me and what I like; and she adds comments that show she has read and really “got” the books, not just picked them out of my list of books I edited. I especially love her description of Millicent Min as “painfully funny,” because that’s exactly what that book is—a perfect little fugue of awkwardness and hilarity—and the fact that Ms. Rhuday-Perkovich (as I thought of her then) recognized and praised the pain in it, not just the funny, made me sit up and take notice of her own work.

(6) She identifies upfront what genre her novel is. This is extremely useful as picture books have to be judged by a different standard than middle-grade novels, and ditto for middle-grade vs. YA, or all of them vs. nonfiction or poetry; and an early-in-the-letter identification of the genre helps me move my brain into the standards of that particular form.

(7) The name “Reginald McKnight” would have signaled to me that this was likely a novel about a young Black man (as that first name and surname are most common in the Black community in the U.S.), and this also would have been a point in the manuscript’s favor, as I’d like to publish more books about and by people of color.

(8) Yes, there is a subject missing here after the semicolon, and I point this out only to say that I requested the manuscript anyway—that the writer and character and book all sounded interesting enough to outweigh the “mustard on the shirt” (in Query Letter from Hell terms) of a minor grammatical error.

(9) “The Guy who’s got game and gets the Girl. . . . In the middle of the cafeteria. In front of everyone.” Coming out of this description, I sympathized with Reggie not just because of the grossness of the event—puking in the cafeteria in front of everyone! Ugh, poor guy—but because I got a glimpse of him in the language. These little details of capitalization and rhythm hint at the manuscript’s voice, and that it’s a distinctive voice, not a voice I’ve seen in many other query letters and manuscripts.

(10) This, the major plot and theme paragraph of the query, says to me that this is a fairly domestic novel, concerned more with local relationships among family and friends than any large-scale external plot to be confronted—which was and is fine with me; my favorite novelist in life is Jane Austen, after all. However, that also means that the characters have to be really well-drawn and well-rounded in order to make readers care as much about the stakes of the characters’ everyday lives as they would about how to defeat the Evil Overlord, say. Here, I’ve already noted that the voice is distinctive, which is a good start, and the rest of this paragraph will bear out the characters’ and relationships’ complexity and depth.

(11) The fact that Reggie’s best friend is white, and that this is remarked upon, confirms my earlier guess that this protagonist is a person of color, and the earlier points in the manuscript’s favor. This next sentence also would have told me that the manuscript delved into racial and political issues, which I find fascinating—all the more so as they often aren’t discussed in middle-grade novels for children; and thus this revealed that Ms. Rhuday-Perkovich wasn’t afraid to tackle big and complex topics in the context of her characters’ lives.

(12) I also love religious questions . . .

(13) . . . and economic issues, so clearly this query is just pushing all my little readerly interest buttons. The reason I love racial, political, religious, and economic questions in books (among many other things, of course) is because we all, even kids, live in a world filled with such questions in real life; and if part of the greatness of art is its fidelity to life, great art, by its realness, must raise such questions. This query letter is saying to me that Reggie and his world and the people in it are all very real.

(14) A very humble, and therefore highly unusual, conclusion to draw; and unusualness + quality realism + ambitious questions + good writing = my interest is piqued.

(15) A biography paragraph in which every fact can be directly connected to (a) Gbemi's knowledge/experience in working directly with children or teenagers, (b) her experience in print communication (which translates as marketing and publicity), or (c) her experience in writing for children. If an author has special expertise related to the subject of his or her novel—if the book deals with a young girl in the world of professional horse racing, say, and the author had been a jockey at Del Mar for two years—then she could also have added (d), her personal knowledge of or experience with the subject; that would have indicated that she was writing from a position of some authority, which is good to know when it comes to an unusual subject or for publicity purposes. In general with queries, any biographical fact that does not fit in categories (a)-(d) should be omitted. Parenthood does not count for (a).

(16) I was especially impressed by the reference to Madeleine L’Engle and Paula Danziger, both of whose fiction I love; and my knowledge of their books and styles told me that most likely Eighth Grade Superzero would have elements of religious inquiry (as the query already demonstrated) and humor, which I would appreciate. (And it does!)

(17) If a writer belongs to SCBWI, that tells me that he or she should be at least somewhat familiar with the submission and publication processes for children’s books, which is very useful in setting expectations on all sides. . . . I can rest assured that the writer won’t be expecting a manuscript submitted in October to be published in book form by Christmas, as in the Query Letter from Hell.

(18) Having made her excellent pitch, Ms. Rhuday-Perkovich exits gracefully, with a direct statement of the letter's implied question—Would you like to see this?—and all relevant information should my answer be yes—which it was! (These days I ask writers to submit two chapters and a synopsis of their novel along with their query letter; this letter was submitted before those guidelines were in place.)

My thanks again to Gbemi for letting me share this letter, and I hope you all enjoy the book it produced.

40 comments:

  1. Like all your posts: very helpful and informative.

    Thanks Cheryl

    Char

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow...where do these people get all these great story ideas??? Thanks for posting!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your annotations are immensely useful and answered a few of my lingering questions about opening lines and the bio paragraph. Thank you for taking the time to post this!

    ReplyDelete
  4. What a helpful post. Thank you so much for posting this query letter and for annotating it.

    Liz Harris

    ReplyDelete
  5. So terrific and so specific! Thank you, Cheryl!
    After not having checked your blog for a bit,I was bowled over by the previous post. Finishing the Hat is my favorite Sondheim song. I saw "Sunday in the Park..." on Broadway over 20 years ago with Mandy Patankin(sp?); it was just beautiful.

    Any chance you will update us on SQUID stats in the near future?

    Betsy

    ReplyDelete
  6. Constance LombardoJanuary 05, 2010 8:52 AM

    What a great letter and extremely helpful! I'll be at the SCBWI regional conference in Atlanta (Spring Mingle) in February--- I'm really looking forward to meeting you and hearing your presentation!

    ReplyDelete
  7. A model query letter. Thanks for sharing. I can't wait to read this book!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow - fantastic help. Can't wait to be at the point where I'm coming back to this post to guide my own query letter's creation.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This post should be circulated among aspiring authors. It's so helpful to not only see an example of a great query letter, but to then see WHY this is a great letter. This can only help!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Just ordered a copy of the book, based on the query letter alone (plus your enthusiasm for it).

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wow, thank you. This was very helpful.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This is great analysis, Cheryl. Very useful. Thanks and good luck to you both on the book. It's sounds great.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Wow! What an amazing ego! Cheryl apparently thinks that book publishing is all about her. Her ideal query letter is from someone whom she has met, someone who has read her articles and shares not just her interests, but her values. In other words, it's her ideal because it flatters her sense of self-importance.

    This article is valuable to me mainly because I now know that I would NEVER want to work with this editor. I bet she puts her authors through hell trying to cater to her self-centered attitude. Thanks for the warning, Cheryl.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Well, Anonymous, I'd rather not work with you either, because someone who doesn't have the courage to put his/her name on his/her opinions is not someone whose writing I want to serve.

    If you HAD had that courage, then I would have said that you raise an interesting point about editorial tastes. I disagree with the assertion that I think book publishing is all about me; there are lots of good books published that aren't my sort of thing, but they ARE some other editor's taste, and I'm very glad that those authors and books can find the right editor, publisher, and readership. More power to them!

    But I have the privilege of picking the projects I want to work on, the same way you do as a writer, presumably. And just as your best work as a writer probably reflects your interests and values (that if you love writing Regency romance, say, you'll do a better job writing a Jane Austen sequel than you would a World of Warcraft novel), my best work as an editor is done with authors who share my interests and values -- for great characters, engagement with political or moral questions, wonderful voices, all those things. I hold these sorts of values not because they're *my* values, but because I really believe in the principles that underlie them -- that moral questions matter, that the best art is the most lifelike, etc., etc. Thus I value query letters that demonstrate the author shares those principles, because that means we have the same literary goals in mind, and I'll be able to be of service to that author in helping him/her craft the very best book s/he possibly can. If the author and I had different values, then we'd be pulling in different directions, and it wouldn't be a good relationship for either of us, or good for the book.

    After that -- well, you'd have to ask my authors about my ego on the page, because clearly I'm a biased source! But equally clearly, you don't want to be one of those authors, so we can both move on with our lives now. Best of luck to you.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I was actually searching for information on how to write a great query letter and I ran into your blog, thanks for the valuable information pal!

    ReplyDelete
  16. hi……………………
    You are a Great while writing in the blogs it is awesome I liked it too much good and informative thanks for the sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I usually don�t post in Blogs but your blog forced me to, amazing work.. beautiful �

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wow! It's awesome blog post here.... really very interesting for reading..... I enjoyed it.
    online kamagra

    ReplyDelete
  19. wow great i have read many articles about this topic and everytime i learn something new i dont think it will ever stop always new info , Thanks for all of your hard work!

    dugi's guide

    ReplyDelete
  20. Oh my!!! You are just too true to be good. How do you manage to write and research on such wonderful things? You have inspired me to work harder now. I shall try as much as possible to enjoy life to the fullest and be satiated with the wonderful things that are around me, which I have been unaware of until now.

    ReplyDelete
  21. It's always my pleasure to read this type of stuff.I am very much interested in these types of topics from childhood and it's my habit to read this.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Fantabulous, out of this world…great man, you have proved the world that innovation is not lost from the universe. I am so influenced by your way of expression; I think I will work to improve mine…great going dude!!!

    ReplyDelete
  23. I just love reading your article. In fact I have never come across such a wonderful piece of work. Of late I have been reading article related to this, but this has been until now the best ever article I may have come across.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I agree with everyone here. Great post. Just wondering how language comes into all of this. In my first YA (which I just considered a novel as I wrote it), I used the words "penis" and "erection " and lost 10 publishers out of twelve in a bid for paperback rights. I know things have changed considerably since then, but don't we YA writers pull our punches a bit for this market? Or is it just me? And should I stop?
    no nonsense muscle building

    ReplyDelete
  25. You have done such an amazing job on this series. I envy your sewing skills and your patience and your diligence. If anyone ever asks me how to sew, I'm sending them to your blog and this series. Congratulations on such an extensive, well thought out and clearly presented set of tutorials
    Dive site listing

    ReplyDelete
  26. What a helpful post. Thank you so much for posting this query letter and for annotating it.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thanks a lot for this great information I like it so much keep posting such a nice post.

    I like this blog o much.


    Smith ALan

    ReplyDelete
  28. You are a Great while writing in the blogs it is awesome I liked it too much good and informative thanks for the sharing

    ReplyDelete
  29. THe blog is full of information and creativity. How do people come up with such fantastic concepts.The description of biography, it motivations me to pen down my thoughts. Thought I like reading lot more than writing I am so inspired by the blog that I will start scripting my thoughts and hope it takes me a long way. Thanks a lot

    ReplyDelete
  30. I am thoroughly convinced in this said post. I am currently searching for ways in which I could enhance my knowledge in this said topic you have posted here. It does help me a lot knowing that you have shared this information here freely. I love the way the people here interact and shared their opinions too. I would love to track your future posts pertaining to the said topic we are able to read.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Like all your posts: very helpful and informative

    ReplyDelete
  32. This is a great post shared here. Thanks for sharing this post.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Like all your posts: very helpful and informative.

    Thanks Cheryl

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hello Great informative article! Thanks so much for sharing your wealth of information. I certainly appreciate the effort! keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  35. That was a great article!
    I am now terrified about my query letter and will make sure it is grammatically critiqued before I even attempt to remotely think about sending it out...

    ReplyDelete
  36. I heard you speak at the New York Conference and took fevered notes. Then, I purchased Second Sight. I have to tell you that it is a miracle. I have been struggling with a high-concept middle-grade fantasy for years. Writing a fantasy and taking years to write anything are new experiences for me, but I just couldn't seem to let it go. Your presentation and book helped me grasp the essence of my project, which makes all the difference. Thank you so much for your generosity!

    ReplyDelete
  37. I couldn't help but notice that your post has a lot of fans named after ED medications. That's an interesting demographic. Hopefully they're all voracious readers.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Cheryl, this IS as great article. It's really great that you share this information with us so we can know what road to take while writing a query letter.

    (and it's such a shame that so many spam messages polluted the comments here)

    ReplyDelete
  39. I agree with everyone here. Great post. Just wondering how language comes into all of this. In my first YA (which I just considered a novel as I wrote it), I used the words "penis" and "erection " and lost 10 publishers out of twelve in a bid for paperback rights. I know things have changed considerably since then, but don't we YA writers pull our punches a bit for this market? Or is it just me? And should I stop?
    دنيا التقنية

    جوجل ناو ستقوم بتذكيرك بمكان سيارتك

    كت كات نسخة أندرويد تعمل على 8.5% من الاجهزة الأندرويد

    كيف تتصفح الأنترنت من هاتفك الذكى بشكل أسرع

    شرح: طريقة إطفاء آيفون وآيباد عند تلف زر الطاقة

    ReplyDelete